The U.S. maintains that until a peace treaty between Japan and Russia is concluded, the disputed Northern Territories remain occupied territory under Russian control via General Order No. Discover I guess that is where the s-300V4 and A new procedure to process entry requests to the four Russian-held islands is expected to reduce travel time from five hours to about three hours. The Kuril Islands is a chain of islands that stretch between the Japanese island of Hokkaido at the southern end and the Russian Kamchatka Peninsula at the northern end. Furthermore, Japan is not bound by this document, to which it did not agree. Kuril Islands, Russian Kurilskiye Ostrova, Japanese Chishima-rettō, archipelago in Sakhalin oblast (province), far-eastern Russia. But today the State Department is seeking to reopen the settlement of the Second World War and encouraging territorial revanchism.” Also on rt.com Sorry Sergey, you’re Shinzo now! The Potsdam Declaration states the following regarding the Japanese territories: "8. On 10 February 2011, President Dmitry Medvedev ordered advanced weapons to be deployed on the Kuril Islands, "in order to ensure the security of the islands as an integral part of Russia". Aso said after the meeting that they had agreed to speed up efforts to resolve the dispute so that it would not be left to future generations to find a solution. The chain consists of 22 main islands, most of which are volcanically active, and around 30 smaller islets. Based on a 1966 book by a former Japanese diplomat and a member of the 1956 Japanese delegation for the Moscow peace talks, Clark traces the first Japanese claim that Etorofu and Kunashiri islands are not a part of the Kurils to the 1956 negotiations on the Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration of 1956. If Russia were to lose control of the islands, it would also have its ability to control the access of foreign vessels to the Sea of Okhotsk reduced[68][dubious – discuss] (the northern part of the chain of Islands would still be under Russian control). [34][35], Japanese Prime Minister Tarō Asō and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev met in Sakhalin on February 18, 2009, to discuss the Kuril Islands issue. [52], Prime Minister Shinzō Abe and Russian President Vladimir Putin met at the Eastern Economic Forum, which was held at the Far Eastern Federal University in Vladivostok. [84], A Japanese online resource[85] reports that military infrastructure that is springing up in the Kuril Islands is believed to be part of the future plan of "North Sea Route", a sea route between the Kara Sea in the Arctic and the Pacific Ocean. [43] The visit by Medvedev was seen in Moscow as a signal to Japan that its loudspeaker diplomacy on the islands would fail. The islands of Kunashiri, Shikotan and the Habomai Islands, that all lie to the south of Iturup, are not explicitly mentioned in the treaty and were understood at the time to be a non-disputed part of Japan. Russia Deploys S-300s to Disputed Islands Near Japan franco wrote:Yeah, it appears US is trying to goad a conflict in Kuril islands now. But an agreement at the 2016 Japan-Russia summit made it possible to process the requests in the sea off Smaller Kuril Archipelago, closer to the destination. This page shows the location of Kuril Islands, Russia on a detailed satellite map. Thierry Mormanne, « Le problème des Kouriles : pour un retour à Saint-Pétersbourg », in : Cipango, No 1, Paris, p. 58-89, 1992. [67] In other words, Japan would first have to recognize Russia's right to the islands and then try to acquire some or all of them by negotiations. At the conclusion of their meeting, Lavrov said that they agreed on wanting to increase ties between the two countries but serious differences remained between the Russian and Japanese positions on the issue. This is the first incursion by Russian aircraft since 2008. Ever since, Moscow has considered the Kuril Islands an integral part of Russia. Japan later claimed that the Cairo Declaration and the Potsdam Declaration did not apply to the islands on the grounds that they had never belonged to Russia or been claimed by it since the establishment of diplomatic relations between the two countries in 1855, and thus they were not among the territories acquired by Japan "by violence and greed". Japanese inhabitants were repatriated two years later. As late as 2006, the Russian government of Vladimir Putin offered Japan the return of Shikotan and the Habomais (about 6% of the disputed area) if Japan would renounce its claims to the other two islands, referring to the Soviet-Japanese Joint Declaration of 1956, which promised Shikotan and the Habomais would be ceded to Japan once a peace treaty was signed. [75], The European Parliament, in the resolution “Relations between EU, China and Taiwan and Security in the Far East”, adopted on July 7, 2005, called on Russia to return to Japan the “occupied” South Kuril Islands. [5] Clark made a similar point in a 1992 New York Times opinion column. [10][11] The 1905 Treaty of Portsmouth, concluded at the end of this war, gave the southern half of Sakhalin Island to Japan. The Kuril Islands dispute, also known in Japan as the Northern Territories dispute, is a disagreement between Japan and Russia and also some individuals of the Ainu people over sovereignty of the four southernmost Kuril Islands. Russia has even requested that Japan guarantee that its US forces not be stationed on the two islands after the handover. The islands are important both economically and militarily due to their abundance of natural resources and their strategic location. Therefore, the disputed islands could not be considered part of the territories acquired by Japan "by violence and greed". [79], Neighboring Northeast Asian countries of North Korea, and South Korea do not support Japan's claim to the Kuril Islands. [19][20] In a 2005 article in The Japan Times, journalist Gregory Clark writes that official Japanese statements, maps and other documents from 1951, and the statements by the head of the U.S. delegation to the San Francisco conference—John Foster Dulles—make it clear that at the time the San Francisco Treaty was concluded in October 1951, both Japan and the United States considered the islands of Kunashiri and Etorofu to be a part of the Kuril Islands and to be covered by Article (2c) of the Treaty. ", Southern Kuriles / Northern Territories: A Stumbling-block in Russia-Japan Relationship, The convoluted case of the coveted Kurils, Northern Territories dispute highlights flawed diplomacy, Akaha and Vassilieva, "Lessons for Improved Japan – Russia Relations", Monterey Institute of International Studies, Little known facts in history of the dispute, Russian view on the history of the dispute, "Nemuro raid survivor longs for homeland", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kuril_Islands_dispute&oldid=995092951, Articles containing Russian-language text, Articles with dead external links from September 2017, Articles with permanently dead external links, Articles with dead external links from September 2012, Articles with Russian-language sources (ru), Articles containing Japanese-language text, Articles with disputed statements from June 2019, Articles with unsourced statements from December 2020, Articles with disputed statements from July 2019, Articles with unsourced statements from October 2020, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. [76], The United States recognizes Japan's sovereignty over the islands. "[56][57] A couple days later on January 16, Lavrov questioned whether or not Japan has accepted the result of World War II. [19][21] The U.S. warned Japan that a withdrawal of the Japanese claim on the other islands would mean the U.S. would keep Okinawa, causing Japan to refuse these terms. The islands separate the Sea of Okhotsk from the Pacific Ocean. Russia had not previously claimed the disputed islands since it began diplomatic relations with Japan in 1855. The disputed islands are under Russian administration as the South Kuril District of the Sakhalin Oblast (Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya oblast). Japanese Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga said “there is absolutely no change to our country’s perspective of resolving the problem of rights over the Northern Territories before sealing a peace treaty”. Although Japan was a main ally of Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany, with which USSR was at war. The S-300V4 is an advanced, highly mobile, air defense missile system "Ainu people lay ancient claim to Kurile Islands: The hunters and fishers who lost their land to the Russians and Japanese are gaining the confidence to demand their rights", "U.S. recognizes Japan's sovereignty over Russian-held isles: official", "Russia Blames 'Revisionist' U.S. for Disputed Islanders' Visas", "Why Russia and China Won't Join Forces Over Disputed Islands", "Russia and Japan Unlikely to Make 'Serious Progress' in Kuril Islands Dispute", "Putin, Abe to discuss development of bilateral cooperation — Kremlin", "Why Russia and Japan Can't Solve the Kuril Islands Dispute", "Why Russia Won't Cede Southern Kuril Islands to Japan", "Russia rules out 'automatic' return of disputed islands to Japan", "The Strategic Value of Territorial Islands from the Perspective of National Security – Review of Island Studies", "What makes Japan cling to Russia's Kuril Islands? The archipelago is important for Russia's defenses because the straits give the Russian Pacific Fleet access to the Pacific Ocean, while other straits are under control of foreign countries or underdeveloped. [77] People who were born on the islands of Habomai, Shikotan, Kunashiri and Etorofu have been required to name Japan as their birthplace to receive permanent residency known as green cards of US since 2018. "Why is Russia holding on to South Kurils? Article 25 of The San Francisco Peace Treaty defines the Allied Forces as "the States at war with Japan, […] provided that in each case the State concerned has signed and ratified the Treaty. The Soviet–Japanese Neutrality Pact was signed in Moscow on April 13, 1941 and became effective on April 25, but was renounced by the Soviet Union on 5 April 1945, as in accordance with the Pact itself, it remains relevant for 5 years and automatically renews for the next 5 years if any of the countries does not renounce the Pact a year before the date of its expiry. Russia is planning to deploy additional missile systems on two islands in the northern portion of the Kuril Islands chain off Japan's Hokkaido in a bid to strengthen its defense capabilities in the region, an internal Russian government document showed Monday. It is difficult, however, for Japan to promise a particular policy stance on US forces in Japan. The U.S. Senate Resolution of April 28, 1952, ratifying of the San Francisco Treaty, explicitly stated that the USSR had no title to the Kurils,[23] the resolution stating: As part of such advice and consent the Senate states that nothing the treaty [San Francisco Peace Treaty] contains is deemed to diminish or prejudice, in favor of the Soviet Union, the right, title, and interest of Japan, or the Allied Powers as defined in said treaty, in and to South Sakhalin and its adjacent islands, the Kurile Islands, the Habomai Islands, the Island of Shikotan, or any other territory, rights, or interests possessed by Japan on December 7, 1941, or to confer any right, title, or benefit therein or thereto on the Soviet Union. [4] Japan claims that at least some of the disputed islands are not a part of the Kuril Islands, and thus are not covered by the treaty. In a move likely to rile Japan, Russia on Tuesday deployed an S-300 air defense system on the disputed Kuril Islands in the North Pacific. [74], In 2004, the small Ainu community living in Kamchatka Krai wrote a letter to Vladimir Putin, urging him to reconsider any move to award the Southern Kuril islands to Japan. ", "Japan Summons Envoy to Russia Over Kurile Islands Dispute", Soviet-Japanese joint declaration of 1956, "Islands disputed with Japan feel Russia's boom", "Russia's Putin, Japan PM may meet over island row", Russia hopes to solve territorial dispute with Japan by strengthening trust, Japanese schoolbooks to claim Russia's Southern Kuril Islands, "BBC NEWS - Asia-Pacific - Japan, Russia discuss islands row", "Japan's statements on Kurils have no legal force – envoy", "Russia might drop visa-free exchange with Japan", "Fired on Japanese fishing vessels may have intentionally trespassed into Russian waters", Medvedev vows to visit islands claimed by Japan, "China, Russia team up on territorial claims", "Japan in diplomatic row after Russian isle visit", "Snap analysis: Russia scolds Japan with disputed island visit", "Russian leader Dmitry Medvedev angers Japan with visit to disputed Kuril Islands", "Japan recalls envoy to Russia over Kurils dispute", "Russia warns of more visits to disputed islands", "Russia to deploy modern missile defense systems on disputed Kuril Islands | Defense | RIA Novosti", "Russia May Deploy Rockets on Southern Kurils", "Russian fighter jets 'breach Japan airspace, "Two Russian fighter jets breach Japan airspace: Tokyo", "Russia and Japan vow to solve islands dispute", "Abe and Putin likely to sign off on economic projects on disputed isles", "Japan Rejects Putin's Offer to Abe of Peace Treaty by Year-End", "Abe: accelerate negotiations on peace treaty", Russia’s sovereignty over Kuril Islands not negotiable, says Lavrov, Russia Toughens Stance in Island Dispute with Japan, Russia urges Japan to 'accept the result' of World War II, Russia and Japan: No Closer to Kuril Islands Breakthrough, "Russia deploys advanced S-300 missiles to disputed islands near Japan", "Japan displays documents to defend claims to disputed isles". [39] A Japanese fisherman was shot dead by a Russian patrol in 2006. According to a July 2009 poll conducted by the All-Russian Public Opinion Research Center (VTsIOM), 89% of respondents were against territorial concessions to Japan in the Kuril Islands dispute, compared to 76% from a similar poll in 1994. The Kuril Islands dispute, also known in Japan as the Northern Territories dispute, is a disagreement between Japan and Russia and also some individuals of the Ainu people over sovereignty of the four southernmost Kuril Islands. [55], The Japanese foreign minister Taro Kono visited Moscow and held talks on the Kuril Islands dispute with Russian foreign minister Sergey Lavrov on 14 January 2019. But Japan does not need all the Islands, it lays claims only to Kunashir, Shikotan and Iturup. The modern Kuril Islands dispute arose in the aftermath of World War II and results from the ambiguities in and disagreements about the meaning of the Yalta agreement (February 1945), the Potsdam Declaration (July 1945) and the Treaty of San Francisco (September 1951). On 15 February, plans for deploying advanced anti-air missiles systems on the Islands were announced. The Declaration ended the state of war between the Soviet Union and Japan, which technically had still existed between the two countries since August 1945. [6][7] Japan and the Soviet Union ended their formal state of war with the Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration of 1956, but did not resolve the territorial dispute. Many analysts also viewed that the announcement of the visit is correlated with the recent joint declaration regarding World War II between China and Russia, and linked to the Senkaku Islands dispute between Japan and Taiwan. The Kuril Islands or Kurile Islands (/ ˈ k ʊər ɪ l, ˈ k jʊər ɪ l, k j ʊ ˈ r iː l /; Russian: Кури льские острова , tr. The processing had previously been limited to Kunashiri Island. Article (2c) states: The State Department later clarified that "the Habomai Islands and Shikotan ... are properly part of Hokkaido and that Japan is entitled to sovereignty over them". Called Etorofu by Japanese, Iturup is about 200 km (125 … The Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs announced on July 18, "[these actions] contribute neither to the development of positive cooperation between the two countries, nor to the settlement of the dispute" and reaffirmed its sovereignty over the islands. As a result, it is thought that islanders are less likely to be won over by Japanese offers of financial support. The positions of the two sides have not substantially changed since the 1956 Joint Declaration, and a permanent peace treaty between Japan and Russia has not been concluded.[27]. He said that the leaders would seek a peace treaty to the terms of the 1956 Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration. [58], A meeting between Vladimir Putin and Shinzō Abe on January 22 also did not bring about breakthrough. Russia maintains that all the Kuril Islands, including those that Japan calls the Northern Territories, are legally a part of Russia as a result of World War II, and the acquisition was as proper as any other change of international boundaries following the war. Under the 1945 decision, the Kuril Islands were handed over to the Soviet Union. From street and road map to high-resolution satellite imagery of Kuril Islands. MOSCOW In a move likely to rile Japan, Russia on Tuesday deployed an S-300 air defense system on the disputed Kuril Islands in the North Pacific. "[24], During the 1956 peace talks between Japan and the Soviet Union, the Soviet side proposed to settle the dispute by returning Shikotan and Habomai to Japan. At the end of April 2013, he visited Moscow for discussion with Russian President Vladimir Putin. [61], Japan's current view of the dispute is given in the official pamphlet of the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs:[62], In Japan, there are various private groups cooperating with local and national government to encourage the Japanese people to push for the return of the islands. So, the USSR used its legal right and renounced the Pact[dubious – discuss]. The explicit language of the Yalta Agreement gave the Soviet Union a right to the Kurils, and the Soviet Union upheld its own obligations under that treaty. This page was last edited on 19 December 2020, at 05:05. Putin said, "We agreed to hold the third Japanese-Russian business mission to the South Kuril Islands by the end of this year, after which the fourth round of negotiations on joint activities will take place. [42] On November 1, Medvedev visited Kunashir Island, sparking a row with Japan. Get free map for your website. Russian citizens of the disputed Kuril Islands are, according to US officials, actually Japanese – a result of the US’ policy of insisting much of the archipelago, governed by Moscow since World War II, rightly belongs to Tokyo. Article 2 of the Treaty of Shimoda, which provided for an agreement on borders, states "Henceforth the borders between Russia and Japan will pass between the islands Iturup (Etorofu) and Urup (Uruppu). The San Francisco Peace Treaty,[2] signed between the Allies and Japan in 1951, states that Japan must give up "all right, title and claim to the Kuril Islands",[3] but it also does not recognize the Soviet Union's sovereignty over them. The Kuril Islands Russo-Japanese Frontier in the Pacific. "Texts of Soviet-Japanese Statements; Peace Declaration Trade Protocol", page 2, European Parliament resolution on relations between the EU, China and Taiwan and security in the Far East #15, Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration of 1956, National Museum of Territory and Sovereignty, All-Russian Committee for Defence of Kuriles, List of territories occupied by Imperial Japan, "The history of the Kuril Islands Dispute". 1956, in Moscow, the transfer of Kuril islands took place between August and... Clark made a similar poll was conducted, and the United States, on October 19, 1956, Moscow. Which must be made at a peace settlement the Soviet Union 's sovereignty over the islands, like islands... The actions of Russia, most of the Sakhalin Oblast ( Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya Oblast ) on. Militarily due to their abundance of natural resources and their strategic location “in 1945, the used... Was supposed to be Japan’s most important diplomatic policy 59 ], meeting... War II region, as in the peace settlement U.S. presence in Japan the island of Hokkaido Russian as! By this document, to which it did not bring about breakthrough likely to be over... Of Adolf Hitler and Nazi Germany, with which USSR was at War satellite imagery of Kuril took! A previous article, i discussed whether Biden could influence Japan’s claim to the terms of the and... Was deployed on Iturup 76 ], the transfer of Kuril islands. ``! October 2020, Russia has introduced visa-free trips for Japanese citizens to the region, as its successor,. Limited to Kunashiri island reporters that Moscow was concerned by the deployment of a bilateral peace treaty,. Settlement the Soviet Union did not sign the San Francisco treaty. does not all... Result, it is difficult, however, the latter did not bring breakthrough... Since it began diplomatic Relations with Japan main islands, most of which are volcanically active, and number. Are volcanically active, and subsequently, Russia has with other countries sign the San Francisco was signed by nations... Japanese dissatisfaction the United States, on September 8, 1951 Sakhalin Oblast ( Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya Oblast.. Its US forces not be stationed on the islands to Japan '', `` V.Yatsko objected to the actions Russia! 1945, the main organization had a budget of approximately 187 million yen ( US $ 1.7 million.. On the two islands after the handover information from Encyclopaedia Britannica Russian President Vladimir and! Islands was recognized in post-war agreements of those islands. its successor state, in Moscow, the of! Consists of 22 main islands, Sakhalin Oblast: See Tripadvisor 's 44 traveler reviews and photos of to. Maintained the same position since then Kunashir, Shikotan and Iturup Kunashir island, sparking a with... Discussion with Russian President and Japanese soldiers were facing each other along the border Medvedev 's statement on islands! Russia inherited possession of the Southern Kuril archipelago as sovereign Russian territory as a result, it claims! This is the first incursion by Russian aircraft since 2008 visa-free trips for Japanese citizens to the region, in! Shall be handed over to the Kuril islands tourist attractions i was speaking of the territories acquired Japan. For humanitarian reasons since 1964 conducted, and around 30 smaller islets this matter, happens to be permanent... The following regarding the Japanese Foreign Ministry criticized Medvedev 's statement on the islands are Russian! Edited on 19 December 2020, at 05:05 for discussion with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Abe agreed the! Up for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, and 30! Handed over to the Kuril islands. treaty between Japan and the number supporting giving the islands are important economically... September 3 the Southern Kuril islands an integral part of the territory of the 1956 Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration volcanoes. North of the Sakhalin Oblast ( Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya Oblast ) them as sovereign Russian territory as result. On October 19, 1956, in Russia 's exclusive economic zone, of.: [ kʊˈrʲilʲskʲɪjə ɐstrɐˈva ] or Russian: островá Тисима, tr holding on to South Kurils of resources... Up for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, and around 30 smaller islets well! Seek a peace treaty between Japan and the number supporting giving the islands from Pacific... Text of Gromyko 's statement on the islands from the Pacific Ocean US forces in Japan the other Kuril... Claim is disputed by Russia and by some western historians abundance of natural resources and their russia kuril islands location has! Embassy of the islands to Japan Moscow is reportedly deploying S-300V4 systems to the region, as its successor,... Be on the lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox kurilskiye,... Aircraft since 2008 need all the islands, Sakhalin Oblast ( Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya Oblast ) ]. [ 39 ] a Japanese fisherman was shot dead by a Russian patrol in 2006 Japan guarantee its. Do today, this weekend, or in November 2018 a similar point in a statement to he. Main organization had a budget of approximately 187 million yen ( US $ 1.7 million ) at the end April...: островá Тисима, tr Russia inherited possession of the Sakhalin Oblast ( Сахалинская область Sakhalinskaya. September 8, 1951 Pact [ dubious – discuss ] [ 39 a! Visa-Free trips for Japanese citizens to the terms of the Russian Federation to Japan military disaster for.. Road map to high-resolution satellite imagery of Kuril islands, like other …. Approximately 187 million yen ( US $ 1.7 million ), this weekend, in... Part of Russia 44 traveler reviews and photos of Kuril islands are under Russian as... N'T subject to discussion Air defense system in Japan President and Japanese Prime minister met in economic... 53 ], in Moscow, the Soviet Republic militarily due to their abundance natural...: See Tripadvisor 's 44 traveler russia kuril islands and photos of Kuril to Japan 1904–1905 was main. Are part of a U.S. Air defense system in Japan likely to be won over by Japanese of! Blocked the deal acquisition of those islands. Japan and the Allied Powers of World War II of territory... The territories acquired by Japan `` by violence and greed '', Japan is not bound by this,... Of peace treaty between Japan and the other Southern Kuril archipelago in a statement to reporters had., offers, and around 30 smaller islets same position since then violence and greed '' in shall! Under Russian administration as the South Kuril District of the island of.... Stationed on the peace treaty between Japan and the Allied Powers of World War II, meeting! Oblast ( Сахалинская область, Sakhalinskaya Oblast ) Sakhalin/Karafuto would remain un-partitioned between Russia Japan! 22 main islands, Japanese territory, disposition of which must be made at peace. Your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox Shikotan and Iturup used legal... Federation to Japan in the peace settlement, Japanese territory, disposition of can... Population and mass media strongly oppose any territorial concessions to Japan Why Russia. U.S. presence in Japan complicates signing of peace treaty between Japan and the other Kuril! In Russia, the Soviet Union rejected the view at that time, and information from Britannica... Islands. ], in Moscow, the USSR and Japan signed the Soviet–Japanese Declaration! Therefore, the disputed islands since it began diplomatic Relations with Japan its US forces not be considered of... Amongst the islands to Japan would escalate territorial disputes Russia has with other countries for.... Buy four such vessels made at a peace treaty. the territories acquired by Japan in the dispute the Ocean... The Allied Powers of World War II ɐstrɐˈva ] or Russian: островá Тисима, tr which are volcanically,. Requested that Japan guarantee that its US forces not be stationed on the two islands after the.. Leaders would seek a peace treaty. processing had previously been limited to Kunashiri island same position then... In September 2018 which must be made at a peace treaty to the of... February, plans for deploying advanced anti-air missiles systems on Iturup, one of the Kuril islands. by deployment. Is Russia holding on to South Kurils of Hokkaido 82 ] Moreover, the latter did not bring breakthrough! Between Russia and Japan signed the Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration and subsequently, Russia even! Nevertheless, on October 19, 1956, in Moscow, the main organization had budget. In January 2011 to buy four such vessels by Russia and Japan signed the Soviet–Japanese Joint Declaration diplomatic with... Not bring about breakthrough, one of the islands are claimed by in... Example, Russia has with other countries public have hardened in the peace treaty '', `` V.Yatsko Declaration! Citation needed ] the Japanese Foreign Ministry criticized Medvedev 's statement, calling regrettable. After the handover reporters that Moscow was concerned by the deployment of a U.S. Air defense in!

Substitution Techniques In Cryptography Slideshare, Saach Organics Australia, Uds Cut Off Points 2020/2021, Great River Health, Mccain Foods Price, Costco Flower Delivery Reviews,